2seaoat wrote:Dreams is probably one of the most intelligent posters on the forum. However, she has her own issues which she does not confront, and when someone actually starts to have a conversation which challenges a position she has taken........she fails to separate issues and herself from what is being discussed. She begins to see the discussion as an attack on her person, and she consistently attacks a person who can make rational arguments. The result is the usual "braindead", mentally Ill refrences............and the lowest blow she has inflicted on anybody on this forum......she called me a lawyer the other day.......mentally ill versus a lawyer.....I don't know....you judge.
I play poker. My read on dreams is that she has been hurt. I consistently see a distrust of men, and signs that someone in her life has betrayed her. Chrissy would call me every name under the sun, but I simply let those words bounce off and let our discussion of facts control our dialogue. It would have been easy for me to take a pot shot at Chrissy.....but to what end. I would only cause her pain, and in the process I would lose her input on issues.....however Dreams is pathologically unable to let mere words remain mere words, and she takes the same as a personal attack. She attempts to size up another person and find a vulnerability......I have seen this behavior from people, and especially young girls who have been hurt or abused. She should not attack you PB. You have the strength to deal with your issues, yet she has not garnered that strength in my opinion, and you should go easy on her, because in my opinion......you could be guilty of the very thing you espouse to want to protect. I think Dreams has issues which are unresolved and some of her anger on these forums give her a good outlet......but her problems remain unresolved, and you calling her out solves nothing.
I think we should all play in the sandbox. We can all learn from others, but we need to be careful not to go too far in our discussions. I have with a couple of posters pushed them too far.....I have done that with the read that they are strong, and I try to never go over the line. In Dreams case, I will push her a little, and she will attack me personally....the usual, but I try not to dissect her personality.......next thing you know she will call me a shrink......
I have come to many of the same conclusions you have stated above, and when she refuses to acknowledge my referenced facts in a post, I simply back off and stop engaging with her... what's it to me? Are other posters going to think I'm a "chicken"?? Big freakin' deal. I am a strong woman who has stood up and defended myself against men using lethal force against me who were twice my size, and one devil who tried to kill me and stalked me across the country several times. I don't need to prove myself on some message board or anywhere else.
SO, while I understand your feelings about being called a lawyer /SHUDDER!/, it does not compare to being called "mentally ill" or any similar reference. Those are VERY personal, hurtful and inappropriate comments/attacks and arm-chair diagnoses to be make in this forum.
Anyhow, back to your post... as mentioned, I had come to many of the same conclusions, so that is all well and good. BUT, while I do not AT ALL think that she's dumb (or anything of that sort) I absolutely do not think that she is of above-average intelligence. I think that she parrots left-wing media in many (most??) of her posts. I would have a lot more respect for her as a member if she utilized original thought and critical thinking. But many of us feel that we are not here to be victimized by a bully... ANY bully. With her, my way of dealing w/the issue is to simply drop it, because I know where it goes, she has been very kind to me privately regarding personal issues (and in that sense, I consider her to be a friend and an ally... I place no weight on political affiliation or posts made on a silly msg board when I make friends), and I simply do not wish to waste my time going 'round arguing w/someone on an issue who -- regardless of the facts and evidence I might present -- will never, ever admit that they were wrong.
PB: TREMENDOUS POST, Sweet Lady!! I think a handful of the members here already know that I've suffered from PTSD for many, many years now (~37), but on your cue, I will also divulge with no shame whatsoever that I have at times suffered from depression, worst of which was during and after my divorce. It's not something that I talk about a lot, but that's not out of any misplaced sort of shame, it's just because I am a very private person. For some stupid reason, it seems "safe" for me to tell you all things that I would not normally discuss in person. A degree of anonymity has a very comforting draw.
PB, good for you for the wonderful work you do to bring depression and mental illness out of the shameful, dark shadows, where it does not belong, and into the light of day. And, I'm so happy that you posted your personal story here. You are a champion, Sweetness.