PkrBum wrote: othershoe1030 wrote: PkrBum wrote:The constitution is clear that the right shall not be infringed... how can you reconcile controls without repeal?
Even our right to freedom of speech draws a line around things like not having the right to yell 'fire' in a crowded theater. In other words exercising that right has limits when expressing it in a way that endangers others.
How can you equate having background checks with keeping firearms away from "law abiding" citizens? Wouldn't a law abiding citizen be able to pass a check?
If y'all can pretend to believe that having an id to vote is restrictive... I can do it on gun control.
What was the penalty for that million + criminals trying to buy a gun? If you're going to start throwing govt solutions against the wall... please try to target the real problem.
Voting and buying a firearm is not a valid comparison. Yes, requiring an ID is restrictive. The problem with the voter ID, as has been hashed out at length here is that there was never a voter impersonation problem to begin with. The tactic was used as a means of trying to reduce the number of people who would likely vote in a certain way.
Requiring ID for gun purchases is a way of keeping guns out of the hands of people who shouldn't have them because they likely are not good citizens or are crazy. Of course if you think people who likely vote Democratic are crazy then maybe the comparison should stand, LOL.Virginia's background check system has prevented 54,260 people, including more than 16,000 felons, from buying guns since it began in 1989.
The total number of transactions denied from 1989 to 2012 also includes drug abusers, the mentally ill and domestic assault offenders, Virginia State Police records show.
During the same period, state police made 12,956 arrests related to the sale or attempted sale of firearms as a result of denied firearm transactions of all types, conducted between federally licensed firearm dealers and customers at gun stores, gun shows and other retail sales.
"It's positive to see that the Virginia State Police are enforcing the laws on the books," said Thomas R. Baker, a criminologist and an assistant professor of criminal justice studies at Virginia Commonwealth University. "The fact that they actively pursue individuals who try to purchase a gun illegally means the background check system helps to not only keep guns out of the hands of those who shouldn't have them, but also helps identify and punish individuals trying to illegally obtain guns."
http://hamptonroads.com/2013/02/stats-show-virginia-gun-background-checks-effective