2seaoat wrote:They are shutting them down at the border. Period. Border enforcement and deportations are the most successful in American history.....also, kids have been coming from south of Mexico on trains for decades and their have been numerous tv specials documenting the same.....nothing new, except we are catching them at a much more efficient border. Another success for the President.
Why do you continue with a blatantly false talkingpoint after you have been shown it's a false narrative?
Are you related to obama?
https://www.numbersusa.com/content/news/february-12-2013/how-obama-administration-inflates-deportation-statistics.html
Padding the Numbers: The Alien Transfer Exit Program
Since 2011,the Obama administration has counted removals from the Alien Transfer Exit Program (ATEP) as ICE deportations,which artificially inflates ICE removal numbers.
According to a source in a Border Patrol field office, “the only reason this group [in the ATEP] program is in detention at all is for the purpose of padding ICE’s year-end removal statistics.”
Created in 2008,ATEP is a program that moves Mexican nationals apprehended in one Border Patrol Sector to another Sector before removing them to Mexico. There are no penalties or bars attached when illegal immigrants are sent back via ATEP and they can simply attempt re-entry. As a result,illegal immigrants who are subject to ATEP can return to the U.S. numerous times only to be counted as removals each successive time they reenter illegally and are apprehended at the border.
From 2008 to 2011,apprehensions through ATEP were counted in the U.S. Border Patrol’s statistics,not ICE’s statistics. However,in 2011,the Obama administration started including ATEP apprehensions by CBP in ICE’s deportation statistics. In the first seven months of 2012,ICE reported 221,656 arrests (ICE apprehensions in the interior of the country),yet reported 334,249 removals (deportations). The 112,000 additional removals were from the ATEP (72,030) and an unknown source (40,000).
Thus,ICE removal statistics had over 112,000 deportations included that previously had never been counted in its deportation statistics.
In 2008,official ICE removals totaled 369,221;
in 2009,389,834;
in 2010,392,862;
in 2011,396,906;
and in 2012,409,849.
However,when ATEP removals are subtracted from ICE’s removals total,
the 2011 number drops from 396,906 to roughly 360,319,
and the 2012 number drops from 409,849 to 324,299.
Therefore,if the ATEP removal numbers are subtracted from ICE’s 2011 removal numbers,total removals are 2.5% below 2008 levels, 7.5% below 2009 levels,and 8.3% below 2010 levels.
If the ATEP removal numbers are subtracted from ICE’s 2012 removal numbers,total removals are 12% below 2008 levels,16.9% below 2009 levels,and 17.5% below 2010.
Year ICE Reported / Total / Actual Total (excluding ATEP Removals)
2008...................../ 369,221 / n/a
2009 ..................../ 389,843 / n/a
2010...................../ 392,862 / n/a
2011...................../ 396,906 / 360,319
2012...................../ 409,849 / 324,299
Padding the Numbers: The Mexican Interior Repatriation Program
From 2009 through 2011,the Obama Administration resumed a voluntary humanitarian interior repatriation program called the Mexican Interior Repatriation Program (MIRP).
First initiated in 2004, MIRP voluntarily returned Mexican nationals apprehended by the U.S. Border Patrol in the Yuma and Tucson sectors.
Since 2008,MIRP statistics have been included in ICE’s overall removal numbers. Without this program,the deportations statistics would be tallied by the U.S. Border Patrol instead of ICE.
Since 2004,more than 116,000 Mexican nationals have been returned under MIRP.
In 2009,MIRP returned 10,560 illegal Mexican nationals. MIRP accounted for 2.7 percent of ICE removals (389,834).
In 2010,MIRP returned a record 23,384 illegal Mexican nationals. Over 6,500 of those illegal Mexican nationals were included by running the program five weeks longer than it had previously run. MIRP accounted for over 6 percent of ICE removals in 2010 (392,862).
In 2011,MIRP returned 8,893 illegal Mexican immigrants. MIRP accounted for just over 2 percent of ICE removals in 2011 (396,906). When both ATEP and MIRP removals are subtracted from ICE’s published removal totals,the 2011 removal total drops from 396,906 to roughly 351,426 –4.9% below 2008 levels,10% below 2009 levels, and 11.5% below 2010 levels.
Year ICE Reported / Total / Actual Total (excluding ATEP and/or MIRP Removals)
2008 ..................../ 369,221/... n/a
2009 ..................../ 389,843 / ...379,274
2010...................../ 392,862 /....369,478
2011...................../ 396,906 /... 351,426
2012 ..................../ 409,849 / ....324,299