Kids aren't rebelling against authority figures because we're not hitting them enough???
You are fucking insane!
No, I am certain that the current results of our educational system are failing. That expelling kids from the structure of school to the lack of structure in their personal lives where drugs and poverty create the context is insanity. We give up on kids. We create the rubber stamp of zero tolerance over the last 30 years which rather than dealing with kids, we pass the problem down the road. Sal, the truth is that in the absence of corporal punishment as an alternative, our schools have abandoned these children, or in the alternative so broken down their spirit that they have been painted into a box of failure as early as the 4th and 5th grade. My wife could identify kids who were given up on by the system by 5th grade, and could predict with remarkable accuracy who would end up in jail or prison. It is not that she is a soothsayer, rather the tools to deal with disruptive students have been so limited that it is either abandon them to a life boat with no chance of survival or sink the ship with all the other kids going down.....we have both.
Yes, I am advocating limited use of corporal punishment in the schools. I would seek statutory guidelines and input from Child experts as to the best way to incorporate a sliding scale of response which does not simply give up on the student but uses all available tools for modification of self destructive behavior which allows students to remain in school and find success. I do not want to see students bullied or abused, but what has evolved is this neutering of male students or simply an abandonment of the same. My friend found that corporal punishment which was fair and defined was an excellent deterrent and worked with male students. How many more generations of kids have to be lost before you understand what really is insane. However, if there are better ways to get male student to not simply give up on education, I am all ears, and certainly do not think corporal punishment is the best or only method.....our toolbox is empty and we are failing.