Pensacola Discussion Forum
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

This is a forum based out of Pensacola Florida.


You are not connected. Please login or register

House Republicans Blocked Critical 'Make it in America' Bill

4 posters

Go down  Message [Page 1 of 1]

Floridatexan

Floridatexan


http://ourfuture.org/20140724/house-republicans-block-critical-make-it-in-america-bill

This week one more example of Republican obstruction occurred – blockage of an important “Make It In America” bill – and one more time not a single corporate media outlet reported it.

The House Republican leadership on Tuesday blocked a bill to secure for American companies critical minerals used in the production of energy-efficient products, renewable energy systems, electronics and other technologies. The result is companies – and the Defense Department – continue to be forced to turn to China to make or obtain critical electronics components.

The China Problem

Put simply, China undermined most of the world’s other sources of these strategic minerals by such practices as underpricing, putting them out of business. Once an industry leaves a country it becomes enormously difficult to start it up again. The supply chain is gone. The expertise is gone. The educators are gone – and so on. And, of course, with the industry goes the jobs and the ability for a country to make a living in the world. A huge investment is required to rebuild all of this.

Now China is the main source (90 percent) for many critical minerals used in electronics manufacturing. China is using that 90 percent advantage to force other industries to come to China. China has been using export controls and other restrictions to drive up the price of manufacturing outside of China. If you simply cannot make or obtain certain critical electronics products anywhere else you either get them from China or go out of business. And yes, that includes our military.

The Bill

The Securing Energy Critical Elements and American Jobs Act of 2014 (H.R. 1022) from Rep. Eric Swalwell, (D-Calif.) was written “to assure the long-term, secure, and sustainable supply of energy-critical elements to satisfy the national security, economic well-being, and industrial production needs of the United States.” It would have increased exploration, research and development, and other national means to secure these critical minerals by coordinating the actions of federal agencies to:

promote an adequate and stable supply of energy critical elements,
identify energy-critical elements and establish early warning systems for supply problems,
establish a mechanism for the coordination and evaluation of federal programs with energy-critical element needs, and
encourage private enterprise in the development of an economically sound and stable domestic energy-critical elements supply chain.
This bill is one part of the overall Make It In America series of bills from House and Senate Democrats.

The Vote

A majority of the House voted for the bill, but House leadership set it up for failure by requiring a two-thirds vote to pass. It was voted on “under suspension of the rules” requiring the two-thirds instead of the normal majority.

The reason? Heritage Foundation and Club for Growth objected to our government helping American companies compete with China. They said that the American government securing necessary materials for American companies to manufacture is “interference with the free market.”

To some there apparently is no national interest, only “market” interests.

Of course, it is not a “free market” because China subsidizes its companies and uses strategic chokepoints like this to take over entire industries. China sees itself as a country with a national interest. Conservatives say we should not.

Heritage argued that government “interference in a functioning market is self-defeating.” In other words, let China have the business.

It really is time to find out if Heritage Action and Club for Growth receive funding from China as part of China’s national strategy to capture the world’s strategic industries. China would be foolish not to. But, on the other hand, maybe China doesn’t have to.

This is important stuff. Really important. You should help spread the word that this happened.

********************

 Evil or Very Mad Evil or Very Mad Evil or Very Mad Evil or Very Mad Evil or Very Mad Evil or Very Mad Evil or Very Mad Evil or Very Mad Evil or Very Mad Evil or Very Mad Evil or Very Mad Evil or Very Mad Evil or Very Mad Evil or Very Mad Evil or Very Mad Evil or Very Mad Evil or Very Mad Evil or Very Mad Evil or Very Mad 

Guest


Guest

Read the text of the proposed bill. Seems to me to be a lot of government hands on with "grants" which will have their hands on the who/what/where/when/why and how's of the proposed business that is called to "make it in America."

More money pulled out of the air by the government to give these grants?

I can see why it was voted down.

Oh but label it something that makes for a 2 minute elevator speech on the ills and evils of the GOP.

 Rolling Eyes Rolling Eyes 

Here's the text of the bill:
https://beta.congress.gov/bill/113th-congress/house-bill/375/text

gatorfan



Two different bills both of which permits "grants" to either train people for manufacturing jobs and the other to chase after mineral research etc - along with grants.

Federal jobs training efforts have been a massive failure in ROI for many years for a lot of reasons, mostly the restrictions guvmint puts on who can receive the grants. Grants under the Make It bill can be up to $20M - yep won't be any waste there with that kind of money.

Once again the House fronts a bill without any real plan for success or any data to suggest it will work.

Certain necessary minerals for high-tech products are mostly found in China. Geographic luck on their part. If there is some data to suggest currently used minerals can be artificially manufactured or found elsewhere at reasonable prices this would be worth looking at.

Or go the other way without knowing and get ready to pay $3,000 for your smart phone or whatever.

We have a problem so lets just throw money at it and hope it goes away. Right?

Guest


Guest

How many more solendras and bloated bureaucratic social programs do you leftists want exactly?

Shewrites and gator have it right... it's not just throwing money at perceived problems... each one increases govt control.

It's flat ridiculous to keep hearing about failure of free market... when in truth our govt has been subverting it for 100+ years.

knothead

knothead

Why don't we just quit even trying to repair the imbalance with China and just run up the white flag . . . . . . . . this would everyone exuberant I suppose!

Floridatexan

Floridatexan


http://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/24/opinion/the-phony-solyndra-scandal.html?_r=2&hp&

Guest


Guest

Solyndra wasnt phony ditz. They stole billions from the taxpayer with
Nothing to show for it

Guest


Guest

Perhaps we need some more success stories like cash for clunkers?

The only reason such govt actions and interventions are accepted is because we have been slowly conditioned. No one here remembers of course... but part of the rationalization to create the fed reserve was to prevent booms and busts.

Instead it's robbed us blind and helped banks and corps collude with the govt. We were subverted into fascism.

boards of FL

boards of FL

As we watch GOP supporters cite all of these examples that they clearly have no grasp on in an attempt to bolster the idea that government simply can never do anything to help its domestic industry, China - a country with a government that aggressively aids its domestic industry - is eating our lunch.

Designed to remain ignorant.

Disclaimer: I'm not saying I support the underlying bill in this thread. Just making an observation.


_________________
I approve this message.

gatorfan



boards of FL wrote:As we watch GOP supporters cite all of these examples that they clearly have no grasp on in an attempt to bolster the idea that government simply can never do anything to help its domestic industry, China - a country with a government that aggressively aids its domestic industry - is eating our lunch.

Designed to remain ignorant.

Disclaimer:  I'm not saying I support the underlying bill in this thread.  Just making an observation.

It's easy to make the assumption that R's block industry support just to be idiots but by the same token it's also not unreasonable to assume D's block support for entitlement reform just to be idiots.

Congress will soon have to decide what's more important - investment in industry research and infrastructure improvement or continued expansion of entitlements where fraud and abuse is rampant. You can't do both because the taxpayer base is shrinking while costs of entitlements are skyrocketing.

What flavor ice cream do you want?

Sponsored content



Back to top  Message [Page 1 of 1]

Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum